WALKSON You are in our Global Site WALKSON
WALKSON
WALKSON

Characteristic Analysis of Closed-Die Forging

What is closed die forging?


Closed die forging is a type of forging process in which the dies move towards each other, encompassing the entire or part of the workpiece. The heated raw material, close to the shape or size of the finished forged piece, is placed in the lower die. The shape of the forged piece is negative and inserted into the upper or lower die. The impact of the upper die on the raw material from above shapes it into the desired forging shape.


Characteristics of closed die forging

1. High Material Strength

  • Improved Mechanical Properties: The process of closed-die forging leads to parts with significantly improved mechanical properties, including higher strength, toughness, and fatigue resistance. This is due to the grain flow of the material, which aligns in the direction of the forging process.

  • Work-Hardening: As the metal undergoes deformation, it becomes harder and stronger, making closed-die forged parts ideal for applications requiring high strength and durability, such as aerospace, automotive, and heavy machinery.

2. Excellent Precision and Dimensional Accuracy

  • Tight Tolerances: Closed-die forging provides excellent precision, with parts being produced to very tight dimensional tolerances. This makes it suitable for parts with complex geometries and minimal post-forging machining requirements.

  • Minimal Flash: The process generates minimal excess material (flash), which means less waste and lower material costs.

3. Material Efficiency

  • Reduced Waste: Since the material is confined within the die cavity, closed-die forging is more material-efficient compared to other forming processes. The amount of material that is wasted is minimized, making it more sustainable and cost-effective for large-scale production.

  • Near-Net Shape: Parts produced using closed-die forging often come very close to the final desired shape, requiring little or no machining, reducing manufacturing costs and time.

4. Good Surface Finish

  • Smooth Surface: The metal is compressed and shaped within the die, which results in a smoother surface finish compared to other forging processes like open-die forging. However, some parts may still require secondary finishing processes, depending on the application.

5. Complex Geometries

  • Versatile Designs: Closed-die forging is capable of producing parts with complex geometries, including intricate shapes, undercuts, and fine details, making it suitable for parts with both simple and complex features.

  • Multiple Operations in One Cycle: A single closed-die forging cycle can produce intricate features, such as holes, grooves, ribs, and threads, without the need for multiple operations.

6. High Initial Tooling Cost

  • Tooling and Die Investment: The initial cost of creating the dies for closed-die forging is relatively high, as the dies must be precision-machined to exact specifications. However, this investment is justified for high-volume production, as the cost per part decreases significantly as the number of parts increases.

  • Die Maintenance: Proper die maintenance is critical for maintaining the accuracy of the forging process and extending the life of the tooling.

7. High Production Rate for Bulk Quantities

  • Efficiency in Mass Production: Once the dies are created, closed-die forging is highly efficient for mass production. The process allows for rapid production rates, making it ideal for manufacturing large quantities of the same part with consistent quality.

  • Cycle Time: The cycle time for each forging operation is relatively short, especially for simpler parts, contributing to fast production speeds.

8. Material Limitations

  • Limited to Ductile Materials: Closed-die forging works best with materials that are ductile and malleable at elevated temperatures, such as steel, aluminum, titanium, and copper alloys. Some brittle materials may not perform well in the forging process.

  • Temperature Sensitivity: The process requires precise temperature control. The material needs to be heated to the appropriate forging temperature for proper deformation. If the material is overheated or underheated, it can lead to defects such as cracking or insufficient shaping.

9. High Forging Press Forces

  • Significant Force Requirements: Closed-die forging requires the application of substantial force, often ranging from tens to hundreds of tons, depending on the size and material of the part. The press equipment must be robust and capable of exerting the necessary pressure without failure.

  • Press Type: Various types of presses are used in closed-die forging, including mechanical, hydraulic, and screw presses, each offering different capabilities depending on the application.

10. Limited Flexibility for Small Batches

  • Best for High-Volume Runs: While closed-die forging is ideal for large production volumes, it is not the best choice for small or custom orders due to the high upfront cost of die creation. Small batches may not justify the investment in tooling and setup costs, unless the production run is quite large.

11. Improved Fatigue Resistance

  • Fatigue Strength: The aligned grain structure produced by the forging process enhances the fatigue resistance of the parts, making them ideal for high-stress applications where components are subject to repeated loading and unloading.

12. Limitations in Size

  • Part Size: Closed-die forging is generally best suited for medium to small parts. Very large components may require open-die forging or other manufacturing techniques. However, larger closed-die forgings can be produced with specialized presses.

13. Suitability for Heat Treatment

  • Post-Forge Heat Treatment: Forged parts are often subjected to heat treatments (e.g., annealing, quenching, and tempering) to further enhance their mechanical properties, such as hardness and toughness. This is a common step in the production of critical components like gears, shafts, and engine parts.


Key Applications of Closed-Die Forging

  • Automotive: Crankshafts, connecting rods, gears, and suspension components.

  • Heavy Machinery: Gearboxes, axles, drive shafts.

  • Energy: Valve bodies, turbine parts, and components for oil and gas equipment.


Closed-die forging is favored in industries where performance, material properties, and precision are critical. By leveraging the characteristics of closed-die forging, manufacturers can produce high-strength, durable components with complex shapes and excellent surface finish, all while minimizing material waste and production time.